Supreme Court Ruling Expected To Make Life Tougher For Patent Trolls

A U.S. Supreme Court ruling Monday is expected to increase the degree of difficulty for non-practicing entities – aka patent trolls – to sue technology companies over intellectual property claims.

The court ruled unanimously against a three-decade old standard that allowed patent holders to sue companies in pretty much any jurisdiction they chose – with a lot of them choosing districts with a reputation for moving quickly and ruling in the plaintiffs’ favor. One federal district in east Texas has been handling about 40 percent of lawsuits filed in the country.

The court ruled that that companies can only be sued for patent infringement in districts where they have a regular and established place of business. And not of lot of them are operating in east Texas. This is seen as bad news for these non-practicing entities – companies that exist mostly or entirely to sue people over the patents they acquired – because they’ll have to take their chances in less familiar and potentially less favorable settings.

This means – and I would seriously not advocate this – if a patent troll wanted to go after Chris Riegel and Stratacache, it has to file in Ohio.

In a slightly weird twist, even though the patent troll issue us mostly about high tech, the Supreme Court case was about flavored drink mixes.

This may ease the troll issue, which has affected digital signage software companies and their clients, but the broader issue us patent law reform, which is puttering along. This story suggest changes are happening, but they need to happen in Washington, DC, which is more than a little topsy-turvy since Jan. 20.
photo credit: romanboed US Supreme Court via photopin (license)

Dave Haynes

Dave Haynes

Editor/Founder at Sixteen:Nine
Dave Haynes is the founder and editor of Sixteen:Nine, an online publication that has followed the digital signage industry for more than 12 years. Dave does strategic advisory consulting work for many end-users and vendors, and also writes for many of them. He's based near Halifax, Nova Scotia.
Dave Haynes

@sixteennine

13-year-old blog & podcast about digital signage & related tech, written by consultant, analyst & BS filter Dave Haynes. DNA test - 90% Celt/10% Viking. 😏😜🍺
RT @sixteennine: White Paper: Connected Kiosks - The Information Hubs Of Smart And Connected Cities. https://t.co/7mP1jYrRSp Free download… - 2 days ago
Dave Haynes