Squabble developing over big agency DOOH transaction fees
November 12, 2010 by Dave Haynes
There’s a really intriguing piece in MediaWeek about the bun fight going on regarding the internal media planning system one of the biggest media buying agency group’s in the US wants DOOH networks to use.
The nut of it is that Starcom MediaVest wants networks to use the system it is putting in place, which was developed by DoMedia. But DoMedia wants to take what amounts to a transaction fee to run the stuff through its system, and MediaWeek is reporting that some DOOH companies are less than thrilled by that idea.
One of the companies leading the objections is Captivate, whose CEO is also the chair of the DPAA, which has its own search and discovery planning tool. That tool was developed by Montreal’s Ayuda Media Systems, which followed the DPAA announcement a couple of weeks back by announcing it was making a buying tool called Symphony available free of charge.
With that context to consider, read on …
The nation’s biggest out-of-home media companies are refusing to list and sell their inventory in Starcom’s new out-of-home database planning and buying system created by DOmedia. It’s not only the big traditional outdoor companies that are pushing back, but also some of the largest place-based out-of-home media companies. The rub is DOmedia’s 2 percent to 5 percent transaction fee tacked on to sales made through the system, a fee the media companies find unpalatable.
DOmedia, which has built a database of OOH companies, is one of several “aggregators” that have popped up to bring some order to the hundreds of small, placed-based digital out-of-home companies. Though there’s been some consolidation, the place-based out-of-home business is still a nightmare for advertisers and agencies to buy.
The biggest out-of-home agency shops, Kinetic and Posterscope, developed their own proprietary systems to handle the planning and buying of the media. In the past couple of weeks, Starcom and MediaVest’s planning and strategy teams have begun using DOmedia’s platform.
“It’s the bazillion alternative out-of-home and digital media companies we want to get a handle on,” said Jack Sullivan, svp, out of home media for Starcom. “Trying to do it with just spread sheets has become too difficult.”
While the digital out-of-home companies agree with that such systems can help advance their medium, they don’t agree with DOmedia’s model.
“We agree with the concept. The question is who bears the cost,” said Mike DiFranza, president and general manager of Captivate. “It’s tough for people to rationalize paying for a database sorting tool. We have to work together to figure out the right mode.”
Even tougher will be convincing the traditional media companies, which have national reach, to put what put premium inventory in the system.
“To take our inventory and combine it with rogue operators discredits what we do,” said one out-of-home media exec, who declined attribution.
“Our policy is we don’t pay commissions,” said Tommy Teepell, chief marketing officer for Lamar Advertising. “I’m not sure it adds value to what we’re doing.”
Rich Langdale, CEO of DOmedia said it’s all about convincing out-of-home companies that DOmedia will bring more dollars to the medium. “We won’t charge more than the value we bring. We want to help the sellers sell more media,” he said.
Sullivan is hopeful the rest of the business will come around. “It’s always tough at the beginning,” said Sullivan. “After only a couple of weeks, a lot of companies have registered, a good 80 percent of them. Negotiations and discussions are ongoing with others.”
DOmedia is about to get some competition. In January, Ayuda Media Systems, a software provider to the out-of-home industry that provides proof of performance, will launch Symphony, a free buying platform for both traditional and digital out-of-home. As part of the service, Ayuda has offered to customize its system for agencies. Ayuda’s current client roster includes some of the biggest out of home media companies such as CBS Outdoor, Van Wagner Communications and EYE Corp.
“Ayuda’s model is a win-win for everybody,” DiFranza said.
So why should anyone care about whose database is being used? If you are a DOOH network operator, your chances of getting a piece of the largest media buys from national advertisers grows exponentially if your media inventory and information is in these internal databases. If your company is not listed, it is doubtful you will be on the plan.
The largest companies, like Captivate and a small handful of others, can squawk because their footprint means their media needs to be in these systems no matter what. The smaller networks don’t have anywhere near that leverage.